I have tried the peppermint, the chocolate mint (both tingly and smell amazing), the pumpkin spice (smells incredible and not tingly so my 4 year old will use it) and the unscented. I love that they go on smooth and last a long time between applications. I work outside in Ohio, so chapped lips are always possible. Not with MadeOn lip balm in my pocket! I have gifted the Vanilla to my mom. It smelled great and I think it has a little shimmer to it.